Ballads of the Broken: Pt. 3

In the poetic verses of Ecclesiastes 3:1-11, King Solomon, known for his wisdom, echoes a profound truth about human existence: "For everything there is a season, a time for every activity under heaven." This passage, reminiscent of lyrics from a Beatles song, resonates with the older and wiser, those who have experienced the inevitable turns of life. It speaks to the heart of our human journey, highlighting moments of joy and sorrow, building and breaking, loving and losing.

Every human being, at some point, will encounter life-imposed brokenness.

This brokenness comes uninvited – the death of a loved one, a diagnosis of cancer, or the aftermath of a natural disaster. As a pastor, I have walked alongside many who have faced such heartbreaking and gut-wrenching tragedies. These moments beg the question: Why? What is the purpose of such suffering? Did God cause it?

The Theodicy Dilemma
This leads us to the theological concept of theodicy, the attempt to reconcile the existence of suffering and evil with a good and loving God. It comes from two Greek words: Theos (God) + Dikē (justice) = Divine Justice

The very presence of suffering is often cited as proof against the existence of God. But, if there were no God, concepts of good and evil would lose their meaning. Instead, it is in our brokenness that God's presence becomes more profound, offering irrational hope that transforms into rationality in the light of His love. God is all-powerful but God is not all doing (cause of brokenness).

Music often mirrors our deepest emotions. In Ed Sheeran's "Supermarket Flowers," written as a tribute to his late grandmother, the pre-chorus poignantly states, "Oh, I'm in pieces, it's tearing me up, but I know a heart that's broke is a heart that's been loved." The song reflects the universal truth that love inevitably leads to heartbreak. It is a life lived in love that truly experiences the breadth of human emotion.

Life-imposed brokenness shatters two illusions: the belief in a perfect world and the misconception of our complete self-sufficiency. It raises fundamental questions about the reason for suffering and the presence of seemingly pointless pain. But it does not disprove God. If anything, it underscores the need for a hope that transcends human understanding – a hope found in God.

Finding Meaning in Suffering
In Robert Ryan’s book, "Irrational Hope," He delves into the purpose of suffering and how we can find hope and joy in the midst of it. It’s a journey from darkness to understanding, emphasizing that hope in God is not irrational, but the foundation upon which we can build a life of purpose, even in our pain.

Why Bad Things Happen?

1. Sin: Sin leads to both self-imposed and other-imposed brokenness. As described in Romans 7:15-17, we often struggle with internal conflicts, doing what we hate instead of what we know is right. This reflects the concept of original sin, highlighting how our own actions, as well as the actions of others, contribute to brokenness in our lives and in the world.

2. God’s Discipline: This concept can be challenging, as it's not about God punishing us for every misstep, like causing car accidents or illnesses as a direct result of specific sins. Rather, it's about understanding the natural consequences of our actions and the complex nature of divine justice.

3. Mystery of Life: Referencing Job 38:2, this point emphasizes the enigmatic nature of life and God's plans. It encourages us to accept that we cannot always see clearly or understand God's ways. Instead of just questioning God in times of suffering, we should turn to Him for guidance and support.

4. Fallen World: Stemming from Genesis 3, this point acknowledges that we live in a world that is not fair, where brokenness, disease, accidents, and suffering are prevalent. This brokenness is a result of the fallen state of the world, but it's a condition that won't persist in the world to come.

These points collectively underscore a complex understanding of suffering, sin, and God's role in the challenges we face. They invite reflection on the deeper spiritual truths that govern our existence and our relationship with the divine.

The Bible tells us that our world is fallen, marred by sin and brokenness. From the self-imposed brokenness caused by our own actions to the natural consequences of living in a fallen world, we are constantly reminded of our vulnerability. Yet, it is in this brokenness that God's strength and hope shine brightest.

The Cross: A Symbol of Hope in Brokenness
The death of Jesus Christ on the cross is the ultimate picture of brokenness transformed into hope and salvation. It wasn’t something God desired, but something He permitted, turning a moment of profound brokenness into the cornerstone of our faith.

In our seasons of pain and suffering, turning to God gifts us with purpose in our pain. It’s about seeking God, not blaming Him; reaching out to Him, not turning away. It’s about not facing our brokenness alone but inviting others to walk alongside us.

Life's seasons, as Solomon so eloquently expressed, are filled with contrasts and changes. But in every season, God remains steadfast, offering us strength, hope, and a promise of transformation. In Him, we find the courage to face each season, not as victims of circumstance, but as recipients of His grace and love.

Posted in